About
Five Pennies Creamery is a homemade ice cream shop inside the Hudson Valley Food Hall at 288 Main St in Beacon. Everything is made on site, and the case rotates through flavors often enough that there's usually something new to try.
Over 100 Flavors
Five Pennies makes more than 100 flavors and sells around 130 over the course of the year, from vanilla and mint chip to banana pudding, Boston cream pie and cake batter, with vegan options too. The menu includes scoops, hand-packed pints and homemade waffle cones. You can call ahead to ask about a specific flavor.
A Classic New York Shop
Founder Dan Levine, a native New Yorker, set out to create a mom-and-pop shop that reflects a classic, sometimes forgotten New York. The name comes from the film The Five Pennies, about jazz musician Red Nichols. After more than a decade serving Rockville Centre on Long Island, the shop closed there in December 2022 and reopened in Beacon in May 2024.
Address
288 Main St, Beacon, NY 12508